Iron Butterfly Options: Overview, Examples, Risks

An Iron Butterfly, often called an “ironfly,” is an options strategy designed to profit from sideways markets. Instead of taking a strong bullish or bearish stance on a stock, the trader simultaneously sells and buys four different calls and puts with different strike prices.

This allows them to profit from a stock that remains relatively stable in price, while also defining and limiting potential losses.

What is an Iron Butterfly?

An Iron Butterfly is a neutral options strategy that seamlessly blends a short straddle with a long strangle. By executing the short straddle, traders receive a net credit or premium. However, standing alone, this position exposes them to substantial losses should the stock make a significant move in either direction.

To mitigate this risk, the strategy incorporates a long strangle, capping the risk at the strike prices of the long options. While the premium paid for these long options reduces the potential profit from the short straddle, it dramatically reduces the associated risk, offering a more balanced trade-off.

Breaking it down step by step:

1. Setting At-the-Money (ATM) Options: Begin by selling an ATM call and an ATM put. The aim here is to profit from time decay, given the high theta of ATM options.
2. Buying Out-of-the-Money (OTM) Options: To define and limit the risk, the trader then buys an OTM call and an OTM put. This ensures that potential losses are capped if the stock makes a substantial move in either direction.

Potential Risks and Rewards

The iron butterfly is a defined risk, defined reward strategy. As a credit spread, its key advantage is the potential to generate income from time decay. If the underlying stock price remains near the strike price of the short call and put, the spread will slowly decay in value as time passes.

However, if the stock does move, the long call and put define your risk to either side. The premiums paid for these long options reduce the overall profit potential, but it also limits your risk in the event the stock has a significant move in either direction.

• Maximum Profit: The maximum profit is the premium collected when placing the trade. This happens if, at expiration, the underlying stock closes at the strike price of the short ATM options.
• Maximum Loss: The maximum loss occurs if the underlying stock price closes beyond either of our long options. The loss would be the difference between the strike prices of either the call or put spread minus the net premium collected.

Real-Life Examples

To see how it works in practice, let’s go through a few real-life examples and potential outcomes:

Example 1: Iron Butterfly on Apple

Let’s assume Apple stock is currently trading at $170. Expecting very little movement in the near future, you decide to place an iron butterfly.

1. Selling ATM Options: Selling an at-the-money call and put at the $170 strike. These options are sold for a credit of $3 per option, or a total of $600 for the combined two contracts (200 shares).
2. Buying OTM Options: You then buy a call at the $175 strike and a put at the $165 strike, both costing you $1.50 per contract, leading to a total of $300.

After accounting for the premium received from the short options and the cost for the long options, the result is a net credit of $3 or $300.

Let’s look at a few possible outcomes:

Outcome A (Minor Bullish Move): Apple’s stock price rises slightly to $172 by expiration. Both long options along with the short put expire worthless. The short call expires with an intrinsic value of $2. After accounting for the premium received when placing the trade, you’re left with a profit of $1 or $100 in total.

Outcome B (Significant Bullish Move): Apple’s stock soars to $178. The short call goes deep in the money, but the long call caps your risk. Your net loss is the difference between the two strike prices minus the collected premium. In this case, you realize a loss of $2 or $200 in total.

Outcome C (Sideways Movement): Apple’s stock remains at $170. All four options contracts expire worthless and you take max profit on the trade. You realize a total profit of $300 (premium received when placing the trade).

Example 2: Iron Butterfly on Tesla

Let’s consider Tesla, which is trading at $320 per share. Predicting the stock will stay around this price, you set up an Iron Butterfly.

1. Selling ATM Options: You begin by selling a call and a put, both at the $320 strike. These options are sold for a credit of $5 per option, or a total of $1,000 for the combined two contracts (200 shares).
2. Buying OTM Options: You then buy a call at the $325 strike and a put at the $315 strike. Each option costs you $3.25.

After accounting for the premium received from the short options and the cost for the long options, the result is a net credit of $3.50 or $350.

Here’s a look at a few potential outcomes:

Outcome A (Minor Bearish Move): Tesla’s price drops to $317 by expiration. The short options result in a combined intrinsic value of $2. Both long options along with the short call expire worthless. The short put expires with an intrinsic value of $3. After accounting for the premium received when placing the trade, you’re left with a profit of $0.50 or $50 in total.

Outcome B (Significant Bearish Move): Tesla tumbles to $300. Both calls expire worthless. The short put is deep in-the-money, but the long put helps limit your risk. Your net loss is the gap between the strike prices minus the net premium. In this case, you realize a loss of $1.50 or $150 in total.

Outcome C (Sideways Movement): Tesla remains stable at $320. All four options contracts expire worthless and you take max profit on the trade. You realize a total profit of $350 (premium received when placing the trade).

Pros and Cons of Using an Iron Butterfly

As you’ve seen, an iron butterfly can be an excellent strategy to profit from sideways markets. However, like all things, it comes with its own unique advantages and drawbacks. Take a look at a few of those below:

Pros of an Iron Butterfly

1. Defined Risk: One of the primary benefits is that the maximum potential loss is defined by the difference between the strikes and the premium received. This gives traders a clear picture of their worst-case scenario.
2. Potential for Profit: Even in a relatively non-volatile market, if the stock price remains close to the strike price of the short options at expiration, the iron butterfly can generate income from time decay.
3. Capital Efficiency: This strategy doesn’t require as much capital as owning or shorting stock outright. By using options, traders can control a larger position with a smaller amount of money.
4. Flexibility: The iron butterfly can be adjusted based on the trader’s market outlook. If they’re more bullish or bearish, they can shift the strikes accordingly, tailoring the strategy to their predictions.
5. Consistent Premium Income: Selling options can provide regular premium income, which can be appealing to many traders, especially in a flat or range-bound market.

Cons of an Iron Butterfly

1. Limited Profit Potential: While the Iron Butterfly comes with defined risk, it also caps the maximum profit. The most a trader can make is the net premium received from establishing the spread.
2. Cost of Execution: Setting up the spread involves at least four options contracts, which can result in higher transaction fees depending on the broker.
3. Risk of Early Assignment: Although rare, it’s possible for the short options, specifically those that are in-the-money, to be assigned prior to expiration, resulting in a position in the underlying stock. This risk is greatest for short in-the-money calls on stocks approaching their ex-dividend dates.
4. Adjustment Challenges: If the underlying stock moves significantly, adjusting the spread to reduce risk or lock in profits can be challenging. It might require closing the position or rolling it to different strikes or expiration dates.
5. Short-term Strategy: Typically, Iron Butterflies are set up for shorter durations. This requires more active management and more volatility.

FAQs